Skip to main content

Strategy Formulation & Resilience

Module: Module 3 — Strategy & Senior LeadershipCode: SFR (SCY)Faculty: Prof. Sumit ChakrabortySessions: 2Status: ✅ Drafted

Big idea​

Strategy formulation is the act of choosing where and how to compete; resilience is the discipline of staying viable when the world breaks the assumptions your strategy was built on. Prof. Sumit Chakraborty pairs the two deliberately: the most carefully formulated strategy ages quickly because the environment is non-stationary, so a resilient strategy is one that anticipates discontinuities, creates optionality, and recovers fast from shocks. The working tools are scenario planning (multiple plausible futures rather than a point forecast), Blue Ocean Strategy (create uncontested market space with the Eliminate-Reduce-Raise-Create grid and the Four Actions canvas), and the resilience cycle (Anticipate → Absorb → Adapt → Recover → Learn). Resilient firms run redundancy without slack — buffer where shocks land hardest, lean everywhere else.

Key concepts​

  • Strategy formulation cycle. Vision/Mission → External analysis (PESTEL, Five Forces) → Internal analysis (VRIO, value chain) → SWOT integration → Strategic choice (cost / differentiation / focus) → Implementation → Review. Non-linear in practice.
  • Generic strategies (Porter). Cost leadership (be the lowest-cost producer at acceptable quality), Differentiation (offer something unique customers will pay a premium for), Focus (cost or differentiation in a narrow segment). Stuck in the middle is the failure mode.
  • Blue Ocean Strategy (Kim & Mauborgne). Escape red oceans of bloody competition by creating uncontested blue oceans. The Four Actions framework: Eliminate what the industry takes for granted, Reduce well below the industry standard, Raise well above the industry standard, Create what the industry has never offered (Cirque du Soleil's reinvention of circus).
  • Scenario planning. Build 3–4 plausible, internally consistent future scenarios (not forecasts); stress-test the strategy against each; identify signposts that tell you which scenario is materialising. Pioneered at Shell in the 1970s; protected Shell through the 1973 oil shock.
  • Resilience cycle. Anticipate (weak-signal scanning, pre-mortems) → Absorb (financial and operational buffers) → Adapt (reconfigure quickly) → Recover (return to function) → Learn (codify and update).
  • Where to place the redundancy. Single-supplier risk, geographic concentration, cash runway, talent depth in critical roles, IT failover — buffer there; lean everywhere else. Resilience is selective redundancy, not universal slack.

Self-check​

A pharma company's five-year strategy assumes a single API supplier in one country at the lowest cost. The CFO asks why we shouldn't dual-source at 4% higher cost. Through the strategy-formulation-and-resilience lens, what is the strongest argument for dual-sourcing?

  • A. Brand value of resilience
  • B. The 4% cost is the *insurance premium* against a tail risk (geopolitical shutdown, plant fire, regulatory ban) that, if it materialises, could halt revenue for months. Resilient strategy places selective redundancy where shocks land hardest — a single-source critical input is exactly that location — and accepts the visible cost to avoid the invisible but catastrophic one
  • C. Dual sourcing improves quality
  • D. It satisfies ESG reporting
Porter's three generic strategies
Cost leadership (lowest-cost producer at acceptable quality), Differentiation (unique offer commanding premium), Focus (cost or differentiation in a narrow segment). 'Stuck in the middle' — trying all three — is the failure mode.

Click the card to flip

1 of 4

Continue learning​

🧰Blue Ocean · ToolFour Actions Framework (Kim & Mauborgne)The official Blue Ocean Strategy library — the Four Actions grid, strategy canvas, and worked cases for creating uncontested market space.📊Shell · ReferenceShell ScenariosShell's own scenario library — the firm that pioneered scenario planning shares 50+ years of working scenarios on energy, geopolitics and climate.📄HBR · ReadThe High Price of Efficiency (Roger Martin)The most concise modern argument for selective redundancy — why efficient systems become brittle, and how to design for resilience without bloat.📊BCG · ReadBecoming an All-Weather Company (BCG)BCG's empirical work on resilient companies — anticipate, absorb, adapt — with quantified evidence on the resilience premium across cycles.
🪞 Apply it — reflection prompts
  1. Locate your firm on Porter's three generic strategies. Are you genuinely a cost leader, a differentiator, or a focused player — or stuck in the middle?
  2. Build three plausible 3-year scenarios for your industry (one optimistic, one neutral, one disruptive). Which of your current commitments work in only one scenario?
  3. List your firm's top-three single-points-of-failure (supplier, customer, talent, IT, geography). What is the cost of dual-sourcing each — and the cost if it fails?

📝 Going deeper. Michael Porter, Competitive Strategy (1980) is the canonical generic-strategies and Five-Forces text. W. Chan Kim & Renée Mauborgne, Blue Ocean Strategy (expanded ed., 2015) is the founding reference. On resilience, Roger Martin's HBR piece "The High Price of Efficiency" (Jan–Feb 2019) is the most concise modern argument for selective redundancy.